“Wouldn’t Be Shocked”: Arch Manning Linked to $13.2M Head Coach’s Team & Leave Steve Sarkisian’s Texas
from Essentially College Football
Arch Manning entered the season carrying expectations that few college quarterbacks have to deal with. But his first full season as Texas’ starter has not been entirely smooth. Through 10 games, he has thrown 19 touchdowns alongside 10 interceptions, already surpassing the seven picks he recorded throughout the 2025 season. The talent is still evident, but the turnovers and inconsistency have put his development under scrutiny. But there is a coach elsewhere in college football who has built a reputation for getting the best out of quarterbacks who arrive through the transfer portal.
That has now brought Manning’s future into the conversation. With one year of college eligibility remaining, the Texas quarterback has a decision to make about whether to return to Austin, enter the NFL Draft, or explore a fresh start elsewhere. Former coach and CBS analyst Rick Neuheisel believes the latter possibility should not be ruled out.
Speaking on The Dan Patrick Show, Neuheisel suggested that Manning could find an interesting opportunity under Indiana head coach Curt Cignetti. According to him:
“I think Indiana will be an interesting place to see if they’ll go after Arch to make him their next one-and-done quarterback,” Neuheisel said on Monday. “I wouldn’t be shocked at all if Arch ends up looking somewhere else. His family is SEC; will Ole Miss love to have him? Probably. Would Tennessee love to have him? Probably. But my point is, Curt Cignetti would be maybe the quarterback whisperer that might take Arch to the next level.”
Neuheisel believes Manning could benefit from exploring a different environment if his development at Texas does not progress as expected. The CBS analyst made clear that he isn’t relaying anything from sources or insiders. His take comes purely from what he has seen and experienced.
Still, Indiana’s recent quarterback history explains why Neuheisel singled out Cignetti. The Hoosiers have brought in experienced quarterbacks from the transfer portal in each of the past three seasons, and each has played a major role in the program’s rise. Kurtis Rourke arrived from Ohio in 2024 and threw for 3,042 yards and 29 touchdowns, helping Indiana reach its first College Football Playoff. A year later, Fernando Mendoza transferred from California and delivered an even bigger return: 3,535 passing yards, 41 touchdowns and just six interceptions. He also won the Heisman Trophy while leading Indiana to an undefeated national championship season.
That run has continued into 2026, although Indiana’s quarterback room is not simply waiting for another transfer. Josh Hoover joined from TCU and opened the season as the starter. Grant Wilson, a seventh-year player who transferred from Old Dominion and is in his second season with the Hoosiers, stepped in for Hoover against USC on November 14. It was Wilson’s first start for Indiana, and he responded with a career-high 305 passing yards and two touchdowns in a 27-13 win. Cignetti called him “the ultimate team guy” and also praised the way Hoover handled his change in role.
That detail is worth noting because it shows that Cignetti’s approach is not limited to finding one quarterback and building everything around him. Indiana has brought in experienced options, developed competition in the room and found ways to keep the offense moving when its original starter is unavailable. But it also means there is no obvious guarantee of a starting spot waiting for Manning if he were to transfer.
Cignetti’s standing in the sport has grown well beyond his work with quarterbacks. He took Indiana to the College Football Playoff in his first season in 2024, then guided the Hoosiers to a 16-0 record and their first national championship in 2025. He is now 36-3 as Indiana’s head coach. That success also changed the terms of his contract. After initially agreeing to an eight-year extension worth an average of $11.6 million annually, Cignetti’s revised deal increased to approximately $13.2 million per year through 2033 following a market review tied to the team’s playoff success.
Neuheisel’s suggestion, however, is rooted in a specific concern about Manning’s game rather than Indiana’s results alone. He questioned the quarterback’s ability to adjust when a defense changes the picture after the play begins. The example he used came from Manning’s interception against LSU, when a receiver running a seam route moved inside and ended up too close to the free safety. Neuheisel felt Manning should have recognised the danger and moved away from the throw instead of continuing with his original read.
“He’s also still myopic in terms of where he goes within what he thinks he sees and where he stays with the ball,” Neuheisel explained.
In other words, Neuheisel’s criticism is that Manning can become too committed to the receiver he initially intends to target, even when a defender’s position makes the pass risky. A free safety typically plays deeper in the secondary and is responsible for protecting against passes that get through the coverage. If the receiver’s route brings him into the safety’s area, the quarterback has to recognise that and adjust. Neuheisel believes Manning does not always make that adjustment quickly enough.
The two games Neuheisel’s comments followed offer a useful example of the inconsistency he was talking about. Against Missouri on November 7, Manning completed 28 of 38 passes for 297 yards and three touchdowns without an interception in Texas’ 34-20 win. A week later, against LSU, he completed 19 of 35 for 174 yards, one touchdown and three interceptions.
The LSU performance was not entirely one-sided, though. Manning helped Texas erase a five-point deficit in the final minutes, converting key third downs before throwing a four-yard touchdown pass to Raleek Brown with three seconds left. Texas won 22-21. So while the interceptions gave Neuheisel examples for his criticism, Manning also showed he could respond when the game was on the line.
That distinction matters when assessing whether Texas has failed to develop him. Manning’s 2025 season, his first full year as the starter, produced 3,163 passing yards and 26 touchdowns, along with 399 rushing yards and 10 rushing touchdowns. He has also won 20 of his 25 starts for Texas. The Longhorns are 8-2 this season, have won four straight games and remain in the College Football Playoff picture. Those results make it difficult to argue that his time under Steve Sarkisian has been unsuccessful.
There is also a fresh development surrounding Manning’s future. On November 16, he confirmed that he would take part in Texas’ Senior Day ceremony before the team’s final regular-season home game against Arkansas.
When asked about the decision, he said, “I’m a senior, so I’m doing it.” But he did not treat the ceremony as an announcement about his plans beyond this season. “I feel like I’ve grown a lot as a person and a player. I’ve enjoyed my time, but I’m just focused on this week, winning this week. I’m not really thinking about the future right now,” Manning added.
Manning therefore still has three paths to consider: return to Texas for his final year of eligibility, transfer to another college program, or enter the 2027 NFL Draft. Senior Day participation does not rule out a return to Austin, and there is no confirmed indication that Indiana has contacted him or that he is considering a move.